Deutsch Intern

    It Depends on Experience


    Patients with colorectal cancer have a greater chance of survival if they are operated in hospitals with a high case load. This is because complications that can occur after surgery can be better managed there.

    Tumours of the large intestine are the second and third most common type of tumour in men and women.
    Tumours of the large intestine are the second and third most common type of tumour in men and women. (Image: iStock.com / peterschreiber.media)

    Tumours of the colon, so-called colorectal carcinomas, are the second to third most frequent tumours in women and men in Germany. The surgical removal of the tumours is a central component of the therapy.

    "Two aspects are important for long-term survival after surgery: firstly, oncologically correct surgery and secondly, the right treatment if complications arise after surgery," says PD Dr. Armin Wiegering, head of the Visceral Oncology Center at the University Hospital of Würzburg in Bavaria, Germany.

    There is a clear correlation between the number of operations performed per year in a hospital and the chance of survival. This was shown by Wiegering's research team in a study whose results are published in BJS Open, a journal of the British Society of Surgery.

    Mortality rates in small hospitals are twice as high

    The results of the study: In hospitals that perform few operations on colorectal carcinomas (an average of six per year), the post-operative mortality rate is twice as high as in hospitals with large case numbers (an average of 50 per year).

    This difference is not due to the fact that complications occur more often in smaller hospitals – because, according to Wiegering, this happens about equally often in all hospitals. Rather, the difference is that patients in small hospitals die more often from the complications. "In large hospitals, on the other hand, there is a sufficient infrastructure to save patients in the event of postoperative complications," said the Würzburg physician.

    Facts and figures of the study

    In Germany, more than half of all patients with colon cancer are currently operated in hospitals that do not meet the minimum case numbers (50 per year) required by the German Cancer Society DKG. With more than 150 cases per year, the University Hospital of Würzburg is one of the hospitals with very high case numbers.

    The study included all cases of colorectal carcinomas that were operated in hospitals in Germany between 2012 and 2015. That was a total of 64,349 patients. Across all hospitals, 3.9 percent of the patients died. In small hospitals the rate was 5.3 percent, in large clinics only 2.6 percent.

    Studies on further tumour diseases

    "This is the first time that we have been able to prove for Germany that there is a clear correlation between the number of patients operated per year and the success of the operation," said Wiegering. His team was surprised at how big the difference is. "We had not expected that the mortality rate in smaller clinics would be twice as high. It is therefore elementary to operate on patients in hospitals whose medical staff has sufficient experience.“

    Wiegering's team now plans to carry out similar analyses for stomach carcinomas, liver metastases and other tumour diseases.


    Nationwide in-hospital mortality rate following rectum resection for rectal cancer according to annual hospital volume in Germany, BJS Open, 10 January 2020, https://doi.org/10.1002/bjs5.50254


    PD Dr. Armin Wiegering, Deputy Clinic Director and Head of the Visceral Oncology Center, Clinic for General, Visceral, Transplant, Vascular and Pediatric Surgery of the University Hospital Würzburg, Wiegering_A@ukw.de

    By Robert Emmerich